Time limits in Italian injury claims: limitation, pre-action steps and the pace of a case

Two, five and ten years: Italian limitation periods, how to interrupt them, the compulsory steps before suing and what to expect from civil and criminal proceedings.
Reading time: about 6 minutes

Few things go wrong in a cross-border claim as irreparably as a missed time limit. Italian law combines short limitation periods for road traffic damage, compulsory pre-action steps that must be completed before a court can be seised, and civil and criminal proceedings that often run in parallel. This guide sets out the time limits that matter, the steps that must precede litigation and what to expect, in general terms, from the pace of an Italian claim.

Limitation periods

Under the Civil Code the ordinary limitation period is ten years (Article 2946). Claims for damages in tort are subject to five years (Article 2947(1)), and claims for damage caused by the circulation of vehicles of any kind to two years (Article 2947(2)). Where the fact is also a criminal offence and the criminal limitation period is longer, the longer period applies to the civil claim as well (Article 2947(3)). In serious road traffic cases, which usually involve the offences of road homicide or serious road injury, this provision often extends the time available, but relying on it requires a careful analysis of the offence and of how the criminal proceedings end.

In medical liability, Law No 24/2017 makes the healthcare facility liable in contract, subject to ten years, and the practitioner, as a rule, in tort, subject to five.

The period runs from the day the right can be exercised. For injuries whose consequences emerge over time, the joint sections of the Court of Cassation (judgment No 576/2008) held that it starts when the damage is perceived, or could have been perceived with ordinary diligence, as a serious injury caused by the conduct of a third party.

Limitation is interrupted by any written demand that makes the debtor aware of the claim (Article 2943), after which a new period of the same length begins (Article 2945). A properly drafted demand to the insurer and to the liable party is therefore the first act of any file, and it should be repeated before each period expires.

When the claim is governed by Italian law under the Rome II Regulation, Italian limitation rules apply even if the claim is heard abroad (Article 15(h)).

Steps that must precede litigation

In road traffic claims, the claim against the insurer cannot be brought until the claimant has sent a complete claim under Article 148 of the Private Insurance Code and the period for the insurer’s response has expired: as a rule 90 days for personal injury (Article 145). In addition, the claimant must, through a lawyer, invite the other side to an assisted negotiation (Article 3 of Decree-Law No 132/2014). If the invitation is refused or not answered within 30 days, or the agreed negotiation period ends without agreement, the claim can be brought.

In medical liability claims, the claimant must first attempt either mediation under Legislative Decree No 28/2010 or a pre-action expert assessment under Article 696-bis of the Code of Civil Procedure (Article 8 of Law No 24/2017). After an unsuccessful expert assessment, the claim must be started within 90 days of the filing of the expert report to preserve the effects of the original application.

These steps are conditions for proceeding. Skipping them does not destroy the claim, but the court will suspend the case until they are completed, with loss of time and costs.

Civil proceedings

Civil procedure was reformed by Legislative Decree No 149/2022, which applies to proceedings started after 28 February 2023. The first-instance claim now requires the parties to exchange written pleadings before the first hearing (Article 171-ter of the Code of Civil Procedure), so that the issues and the evidence are defined early. A simplified procedure is available where the facts are not seriously disputed or the evidence is documentary (Articles 281-decies and following).

In personal injury cases the decisive phase is usually the court-appointed expert assessment, in which a forensic doctor, and in medical cases a specialist, examines the claimant and the records. The parties’ experts take part and file observations on the draft report.

A first-instance judgment can be appealed to the Court of Appeal and then, on points of law, to the Court of Cassation. Italian civil proceedings are long by European standards, and several years from the first claim to a final judgment is not unusual. This is one reason why most serious claims settle, and why interim payments matter.

The criminal proceedings

When the accident constitutes an offence, the criminal proceedings start ex officio and often move faster than any civil claim in establishing the facts. The victim, or the family, can take part as injured parties during the investigation and join the trial as civil parties. The criminal court can award an interim payment and leave the full assessment of damages to the civil courts.

Since the 2021 reform of criminal procedure, for offences committed from 1 January 2020, appeal proceedings that exceed set time limits cannot continue (Article 344-bis of the Code of Criminal Procedure). In that case the civil party’s claim is transferred to the civil courts (Article 578(1-bis)), which then decide it on the evidence already gathered. Strategy in the criminal case should take this possibility into account from the start.

Costs

As a rule the losing party pays the winning party’s legal costs, assessed by the court on the basis of ministerial parameters (Article 91 of the Code of Civil Procedure and Ministerial Decree No 55/2014), although costs may be shared when there are justified reasons. Refusing a proposal made during the proceedings, or failing to take part in a compulsory mediation or negotiation, can have consequences for costs.

Questions we are often asked

The accident happened eighteen months ago. Is it too late?

Not necessarily, but it is urgent. Check whether a written demand has already been sent, whether the facts constitute an offence that extends the limitation period, and send a demand that interrupts limitation immediately.

Does a claim filed abroad interrupt Italian limitation?

A judicial claim and a written demand interrupt limitation under Articles 2943 and 2945; whether a particular foreign act has that effect should be assessed case by case. The safest course is to send a formal written demand directly to the Italian insurer and liable party.

Can we go straight to court?

Not in road traffic or medical liability cases: the statutory claim, the assisted negotiation or, for medical cases, mediation or a pre-action expert assessment must come first.

Sources

  • Civil Code, Articles 2943, 2945, 2946, 2947: Normattiva
  • Private Insurance Code, Articles 145 and 148: Normattiva
  • Decree-Law No 132/2014, Article 3: Normattiva
  • Law No 24/2017, Article 8; Legislative Decree No 28/2010: Normattiva
  • Code of Civil Procedure, Articles 91, 171-ter, 281-decies, 696-bis; Legislative Decree No 149/2022: Normattiva
  • Code of Criminal Procedure, Articles 344-bis and 578: Normattiva
  • Court of Cassation, joint sections, judgment No 576 of 11 January 2008: Corte di Cassazione
  • Regulation (EC) No 864/2007 (Rome II), Article 15(h): EUR-Lex

If a limitation period may be running on a claim with an Italian connection, write to us now. We reply personally and tell you what must be done first.

Written by
Picture of Avv. Roberta Scarpellini
Avv. Roberta Scarpellini

Member of the Milan Bar, leading Studio Legale Scarpellini. The firm handles only cases of serious personal injury and death, from road traffic collisions and medical liability, and works with law firms abroad on claims with an Italian connection. President of NEVRA ETS.

Avv. Roberta Scarpellini · Milan Bar · studioscarpellini.com

A note. This guide provides general information on Italian law, up to date at the date shown, and is not a substitute for advice on a specific case. References to legislation and case law are to the Italian texts unless stated otherwise.

Working on a case with an Italian connection?

Tell us about the case

Every enquiry is read personally. We reply with a first view on what can be done in Italy, which time limits apply and what your client should not sign. See how we work with foreign law firms.

More guides

Chat with us on WhatsApp