Future care, assistance and the capitalisation of annual losses

Building the claim for catastrophic injuries: care needs, costs in the country of residence, capitalisation coefficients and annuities under Article 2057 of the Civil Code.
Reading time: about 4 minutes

In catastrophic injury cases, such as brain injury, spinal cord injury or multiple amputations, the largest part of the claim is often not the non-pecuniary damage but the cost of the victim’s future needs: care and assistance, therapy, equipment, adaptation of the home and vehicle, and the income the victim will never earn. Italian law compensates these losses in full, but it requires them to be specifically proved and properly calculated. This guide explains how.

Future pecuniary losses are recoverable under Article 1223 of the Civil Code, applied to tort by Article 2056, as consequences of the injury that are reasonably certain to occur. The claimant must prove the need and its cost; where the exact amount cannot be proved, the court may assess it equitably (Article 1226), but only once the existence of the loss is established.

Building the care claim

The starting point is a clinical and medico-legal assessment of the victim’s needs: the hours and type of assistance required, nursing or professional care, therapy and rehabilitation, medication, aids and equipment and their replacement over time, transport, and the adaptation of the home. In complex cases this takes the form of a care plan prepared by specialists in rehabilitation and care.

Each item is then costed with evidence: quotes, contracts, tariffs, and, where the victim lives abroad, evidence of the costs in the country of residence. Recital 33 of the Rome II Regulation invites courts, in road traffic cases, to take into account the actual circumstances of the victim, including the costs of after-care and medical attention. Italian courts recognise the value of care provided free of charge by family members, which is compensable even if no money is paid, because it represents a need the injury created.

Loss of earnings and earning capacity

For a victim of working age, the claim includes past loss of earnings and the reduction of future earning capacity. Italian courts distinguish between the generic capacity to work, part of biological damage, and the specific capacity to carry on one’s own occupation, whose loss is a pecuniary damage. The forensic expert must assess the effect of the impairment on the specific job, and the income must be proved with tax and employment records. For a child or young person with no earnings history, the court will assess the likely future earnings on the basis of the family’s circumstances, education and prospects.

From annual amounts to a capital sum

Future losses are usually expressed as an annual amount and converted into a capital sum. The Milan Observatory publishes, with the 2024 edition of its tables, a table for the early capitalisation of an annuity, with coefficients based on age, sex, life expectancy and an interest rate. Courts have increasingly favoured coefficients that reflect current life expectancy and realistic interest rates, abandoning older tables that significantly undervalued future losses.

Life expectancy itself may be in dispute: severe injuries can reduce it, and the forensic and clinical experts must address the point explicitly.

Annuity instead of a lump sum

Under Article 2057 of the Civil Code, where permanent damage is involved, the court may, taking into account the conditions of the parties and the nature of the damage, award an annuity instead of a lump sum, with appropriate guarantees. Annuities are rare in practice, but they can be an option in settlements for the most serious cases, where the uncertainty about life expectancy is great.

Benefits received

Where public bodies, such as the Italian work-injury insurer INAIL, pay benefits for the same loss and have a right of recovery against the wrongdoer, those benefits are deducted from the damages, while benefits without a recovery mechanism, such as a survivor’s pension, are not (Court of Cassation, joint sections, judgments Nos 12564 to 12567/2018). Benefits from foreign social security systems raise similar questions, and their recovery rights must be addressed in any settlement.

Questions we are often asked

Our client lives in a country where care is more expensive than in Italy. Which costs count?

The actual costs the victim will incur, where they live, if properly proved. The applicable law does not impose Italian prices.

Is care by family members compensated?

Yes. The need for assistance is a loss even if relatives provide it for free.

Which capitalisation coefficients are used?

Courts commonly use those published with the Milan tables, which reflect current life expectancy and interest rates. The choice should be argued explicitly.

Sources

  • Civil Code, Articles 1223, 1226, 2056, 2057: Normattiva
  • Osservatorio sulla Giustizia civile di Milano, Tabelle 2024, including the table for the capitalisation of an annuity: Tribunale di Milano
  • Regulation (EC) No 864/2007 (Rome II), Recital 33: EUR-Lex
  • Court of Cassation, joint sections, judgments Nos 12564–12567 of 22 May 2018: Corte di Cassazione

If your client faces lifelong care needs after an injury in Italy, tell us about the case: we reply personally.

Written by
Picture of Avv. Roberta Scarpellini
Avv. Roberta Scarpellini

Member of the Milan Bar, leading Studio Legale Scarpellini. The firm handles only cases of serious personal injury and death, from road traffic collisions and medical liability, and works with law firms abroad on claims with an Italian connection. President of NEVRA ETS.

Avv. Roberta Scarpellini · Milan Bar · studioscarpellini.com

A note. This guide provides general information on Italian law, up to date at the date shown, and is not a substitute for advice on a specific case. References to legislation and case law are to the Italian texts unless stated otherwise.

Working on a case with an Italian connection?

Tell us about the case

Every enquiry is read personally. We reply with a first view on what can be done in Italy, which time limits apply and what your client should not sign. See how we work with foreign law firms.

More guides

Chat with us on WhatsApp