Infections contracted in hospital and failures in the organisation of care are among the most common grounds of medical liability claims in Italy. They differ from claims about a doctor’s individual error: the question is not what a particular practitioner did, but whether the facility did what it should have done to prevent the harm. Italian case law has developed specific rules on what each side must prove, and they are favourable to patients who prepare the case properly.
The contractual liability of the facility
Under Article 7(1) of Law No 24/2017 and Articles 1218 and 1228 of the Civil Code, the healthcare facility is liable in contract for the harm caused to patients, both through the conduct of its staff and through deficiencies of its own organisation. The latter is a liability of the facility as such: understaffing, inadequate equipment, defective hygiene protocols, failures of monitoring and coordination.
Hospital-acquired infections: the burden of proof
In judgment No 6386 of 3 March 2023, the Court of Cassation set out a framework that has since been followed and confirmed, including in order No 17145/2025. The liability of the facility for infections is not strict. The patient must prove, also by presumptions, that the infection was contracted in hospital. To that end the court considers three criteria: a temporal criterion, the time elapsed between admission or discharge and the onset of the infection; a topographical criterion, the site of the infection in relation to the procedure; and a clinical criterion, the specific nature of the infection and the preventive measures that would have been required.
Once the patient has discharged that burden, the facility must prove that it adopted, and actually applied, all the organisational, procedural and structural measures needed to prevent the risk of infection. The Court listed the measures the facility should be able to document, among them protocols for disinfection and sterilisation, the handling of linen and waste, the training and supervision of staff, surveillance of infections and the monitoring of the specific risk. Producing written protocols is not enough: the facility must prove their concrete application in the period of the patient’s stay.
The judgment also clarified the position of the facility’s managers, whose liability depends on proof of their personal fault in the organisation of prevention.
Organisational failures
Beyond infections, organisational liability covers a wide range of situations: delays in diagnosis or treatment due to lack of staff or equipment; falls of patients who should have been monitored; failures to transfer a patient to a better equipped facility; poor coordination between departments; loss of records. In these cases the patient proves the treatment relationship and the causal link between the deficiency and the harm, and the facility must prove that it performed correctly or that the outcome was due to an unforeseeable and unavoidable cause.
Evidence that decides these cases
The medical record is the starting point, but in infection and organisational cases it is not enough. The claimant should request the facility’s infection-control protocols, surveillance data and the records showing their application, nursing records and staffing information. Article 4 of Law No 24/2017 requires facilities to provide clinical documentation promptly and to publish data on the compensation paid in the previous five years. The court-appointed experts will be asked to verify the documentation against the measures the case law requires, and the claimant’s party experts should do so first.
Relatives’ claims
Where the infection or the organisational failure causes the patient’s death, the close relatives have claims in their own right for the loss of the family relationship, and the heirs inherit the patient’s claims. Judgment No 6386/2023 also addressed what relatives must allege and prove in such cases.
Questions we are often asked
Is the hospital automatically liable for any infection?
No. The patient must show, also through presumptions, that the infection was contracted there; the facility can then avoid liability by proving it applied all necessary preventive measures.
Is a written protocol a sufficient defence?
No. The facility must prove the concrete application of the measures during the patient’s stay.
Which limitation period applies?
Ten years against the facility, whose liability is contractual (Article 2946 of the Civil Code), running from the moment the damage and its cause could be perceived.
Sources
- Law No 24/2017, Articles 4 and 7: Normattiva
- Civil Code, Articles 1218, 1228, 2946: Normattiva
- Court of Cassation, Third Civil Section, judgment No 6386 of 3 March 2023; order No 17145/2025: Corte di Cassazione
If your client suffered an infection or an organisational failure in an Italian hospital, tell us about the case: we reply personally.