Suing an Italian motor insurer from another Member State: the Odenbreit route

How Articles 11 and 13 of Brussels I bis allow a direct action at the claimant’s domicile, who can rely on it, and the practical consequences of suing at home under Italian law.
Reading time: about 5 minutes

For a client injured in Italy who lives in another Member State, the most practical question is often not which law applies, but where the claim can be brought. EU law gives a clear answer for claims against the liability insurer: the injured party can usually sue it at home. This guide explains the basis of that rule, who can and cannot rely on it, and what it means in practice to litigate at home a claim that will be decided under Italian law.

The rule: insurance matters in Brussels I bis

Section 3 of Chapter II of Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012 (Brussels I bis), Articles 10 to 16, contains special jurisdiction rules for insurance, designed to protect the party regarded as economically weaker. Under Article 11(1)(b), an insurer domiciled in a Member State may be sued in another Member State, in the courts of the place where the claimant is domiciled, when the action is brought by the policyholder, the insured or a beneficiary. Article 13(2) extends Articles 10, 11 and 12 to actions brought by the injured party directly against the insurer, where such direct actions are permitted.

Odenbreit

In FBTO Schadeverzekeringen v Odenbreit (C-463/06, judgment of 13 December 2007), the Court of Justice held that the reference in what is now Article 13(2) to Article 11(1)(b) must be read as allowing the injured party to bring an action directly against the insurer before the courts of the place in a Member State where the injured party is domiciled, provided that a direct action is permitted and the insurer is domiciled in a Member State. The Court relied on the protective purpose of the insurance rules and on the Motor Insurance Directives, which give the injured party a direct right against the insurer.

The condition that a direct action be permitted is satisfied in Italian motor claims: Article 144 of the Private Insurance Code gives the injured party a direct action against the compulsory motor insurer. Article 18 of the Rome II Regulation confirms that the direct action is available if either the law applicable to the tort or the law applicable to the insurance contract provides for it. Since 2024 Italian law also grants a direct action against the insurer of healthcare facilities (Article 12 of Law No 24/2017).

Who can rely on it

The protective forum is reserved for parties in a weaker position. The Court of Justice has drawn the line in a series of judgments. A social security institution that has compensated the victim and sues the insurer by statutory subrogation cannot use it (Vorarlberger Gebietskrankenkasse, C-347/08). An employer that continued to pay the salary of an injured employee and acts by subrogation can, because it is not in a stronger position than the employee (KABEG, C-340/16, judgment of 20 July 2017). A person who acquires claims professionally, such as a claims management company acting on assignment, cannot (Hofsoe, C-106/17, judgment of 31 January 2018).

Heirs and relatives claiming their own losses are generally treated as injured parties. Their position should nonetheless be checked case by case, especially where the claim is brought by a mixture of relatives domiciled in different countries.

Joining the driver and the policyholder

Article 13(3) allows the insurer, where the law governing the direct action so provides, to have the policyholder or insured joined as parties in the same court. Under Italian law the owner of the vehicle must be joined in the direct action (Article 144(3) of the Private Insurance Code). A claim brought abroad should anticipate this.

What changes, and what does not, when suing at home

The applicable law does not follow the forum. Under Article 4(1) of the Rome II Regulation, an accident in Italy is normally governed by Italian law, and Article 15 extends that law to the assessment of damage and to limitation. The home court will therefore apply Italian heads of damage, Italian valuation tables and Italian limitation periods. It will need evidence of Italian law and of Italian practice, which in most systems means expert evidence on foreign law.

Procedure follows the forum: the rules on evidence, on court experts, on costs and on interest for the period of the proceedings. These can significantly affect the outcome, and a careful comparison between the home forum and the Italian courts is part of the strategy, not a formality.

The Italian pre-action requirements are a subtler issue. Whether a court abroad must require the claim under Article 148 of the Private Insurance Code or the assisted negotiation under Article 3 of Decree-Law No 132/2014 depends on how those requirements are characterised, procedural or substantive. In practice, sending a complete Article 148 claim is always advisable: it starts the insurer’s duty to respond, interrupts limitation and is required if the case ends up in Italy.

Outside the European Union

The Odenbreit route is available only to claimants domiciled in a Member State suing an insurer domiciled in a Member State. For Switzerland, Norway and Iceland, the 2007 Lugano Convention contains equivalent insurance rules. Claimants domiciled in the United Kingdom or other third countries cannot rely on Brussels I bis, and serious claims against Italian insurers by such claimants are usually brought in Italy.

Questions we are often asked

Can the family of a Maltese victim sue the Italian insurer in Malta?

As a rule, yes, each relative domiciled in Malta suing as an injured party. The claim will be governed by Italian law.

Does suing at home stop limitation running in Italy?

A claim filed abroad may have that effect, but the safest course is to send a written demand directly to the Italian insurer, which interrupts limitation under Article 2943 of the Italian Civil Code.

Is suing at home always better?

Not always. It is often more convenient for the client, but requires proof of Italian law and practice, and the home court may be less familiar with the valuation of Italian heads of damage.

Sources

  • Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012, Articles 10–16, 18: EUR-Lex
  • Court of Justice, C-463/06 Odenbreit: EUR-Lex
  • Court of Justice, C-347/08 Vorarlberger Gebietskrankenkasse: EUR-Lex
  • Court of Justice, C-340/16 KABEG: EUR-Lex
  • Court of Justice, C-106/17 Hofsoe: EUR-Lex
  • Regulation (EC) No 864/2007 (Rome II), Articles 4, 15, 18: EUR-Lex
  • Private Insurance Code, Articles 144 and 148: Normattiva
  • Law No 24/2017, Article 12: Normattiva

If your client may be able to sue the Italian insurer at home, we can help assess the choice of forum. tell us about the case: we reply personally.

Written by
Picture of Avv. Roberta Scarpellini
Avv. Roberta Scarpellini

Member of the Milan Bar, leading Studio Legale Scarpellini. The firm handles only cases of serious personal injury and death, from road traffic collisions and medical liability, and works with law firms abroad on claims with an Italian connection. President of NEVRA ETS.

Avv. Roberta Scarpellini · Milan Bar · studioscarpellini.com

A note. This guide provides general information on Italian law, up to date at the date shown, and is not a substitute for advice on a specific case. References to legislation and case law are to the Italian texts unless stated otherwise.

Working on a case with an Italian connection?

Tell us about the case

Every enquiry is read personally. We reply with a first view on what can be done in Italy, which time limits apply and what your client should not sign. See how we work with foreign law firms.

More guides

Chat with us on WhatsApp