When a client domiciled outside Italy is seriously injured in Italy, or loses a family member there, two questions arise before any other: which courts can hear the claim, and which law will decide it. They are often confused, and they do not always have the same answer. A Maltese, German or Irish court may well have jurisdiction over the Italian insurer and still have to apply Italian law, Italian heads of damage and Italian limitation periods.
This guide sets out the framework that applies within the European Union to road traffic and medical liability claims, the points on which the answer changes for claimants from outside the Union, and the practical consequences for the choice of forum.
Two separate questions
Jurisdiction is governed, between Member States, by Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012 (Brussels I bis). The applicable law is governed by Regulation (EC) No 864/2007 (Rome II) for non-contractual obligations, and by Regulation (EC) No 593/2008 (Rome I) where the claim is contractual, as it can be against an Italian hospital. Procedure, including evidence and costs, follows the law of the court seised.
The distinction matters because the forum affects the practicalities of the case (language, cost, the experience of the judge with personal injury valuation), while the applicable law determines what can be claimed and how much it is worth.
Jurisdiction under Brussels I bis
The general rule is that a defendant is sued in the courts of the Member State where it is domiciled (Article 4). In tort, the claimant may also sue in the courts of the place where the harmful event occurred (Article 7(2)), which in a road accident in Italy points to the Italian courts. The place where the claimant later suffers indirect financial consequences does not, on its own, found jurisdiction.
The rules that matter most in practice are those on insurance. Article 11(1)(b) allows a policyholder, insured or beneficiary to sue the insurer in the courts of their own domicile, and Article 13(2) extends this to the injured party bringing a direct action, where such an action is permitted. Italian law grants a direct action against the compulsory motor insurer (Article 144 of the Private Insurance Code) and, since the implementing rules came into force, against the insurer of healthcare facilities (Article 12 of Law No 24/2017).
In FBTO Schadeverzekeringen v Odenbreit (C-463/06), the Court of Justice held that the injured party domiciled in a Member State can therefore sue the liability insurer, domiciled in another Member State, before the courts of the place where the injured party is domiciled. The decision concerned the earlier Regulation, but the rule has been carried over into Brussels I bis.
The Court has also set limits on who can use this protective forum. A social security institution that has paid benefits and acts by subrogation cannot rely on it (Vorarlberger Gebietskrankenkasse, C-347/08), because the special insurance rules protect the weaker party. Heirs and close relatives claiming their own losses are generally treated as injured parties, but the point should be checked against the Court’s case law for the particular claimant.
The applicable law under Rome II
For a road traffic accident or another tort, Article 4(1) of Rome II points to the law of the country where the damage occurs, which is the country of the accident, regardless of where the indirect consequences are felt. If the person liable and the injured person were both habitually resident in the same country when the damage occurred, the law of that country applies instead (Article 4(2)). Finally, if the tort is manifestly more closely connected with another country, that law applies (Article 4(3)).
The applicable law governs far more than liability. Article 15 lists, among other things, the existence, nature and assessment of damage (Article 15(c)), the persons entitled to compensation (Article 15(f)) and the rules of prescription and limitation (Article 15(h)). A claim governed by Italian law is therefore valued with Italian heads of damage and Italian tables, and is subject to Italian limitation periods, even if it is heard abroad.
Two further provisions are relevant in road traffic cases. Article 17 requires the court to take into account the rules of safety and conduct in force at the place of the accident. Article 18 allows the injured person to bring a direct action against the insurer if either the law applicable to the tort or the law applicable to the insurance contract provides for it. Recital 33 adds that, when quantifying damages in road traffic cases, the court should take into account the actual circumstances of the victim, including the costs of after-care and medical attention in the country of residence.
The 1971 Hague Convention
Several Member States, including France, Spain, Belgium, the Netherlands and Austria, are parties to the Hague Convention of 4 May 1971 on the law applicable to traffic accidents, which takes precedence over Rome II in their courts (Article 28 of Rome II). Its connecting factors differ. Italy and Malta are not parties, but the Convention can matter when a claimant domiciled in a Convention State chooses to sue at home.
Medical liability: contract or tort
Under Italian law a hospital or clinic is liable to the patient in contract, while an employed doctor is liable in tort (Article 7 of Law No 24/2017). For treatment received in Italy, both Rome I, which for services points to the habitual residence of the provider (Article 4(1)(b)), and Rome II normally lead to Italian law. The Italian pre-action requirements of Article 8 of Law No 24/2017, mediation or a pre-action expert assessment, apply to proceedings in Italy.
Claimants from outside the European Union
Brussels I bis protects claimants domiciled in a Member State. A claimant domiciled in the United Kingdom, Switzerland or another third country cannot rely on Article 13(2) to sue an Italian insurer at home. Whether the home courts take jurisdiction then depends on their own rules or on other instruments, such as the Lugano Convention for Switzerland, Norway and Iceland, and enforcing a foreign judgment in Italy raises additional issues. In practice, serious claims by non-EU residents against Italian insurers are usually conducted in Italy.
Rome II, by contrast, has universal application (Article 3): an Italian court applies it whatever the nationality or residence of the parties, so Italian law will normally govern an accident that happened in Italy.
Choosing the forum in practice
Suing at home has obvious advantages for the client: language, proximity, familiar procedure. It also has costs that are easy to underestimate. The home court will need evidence of Italian law and of Italian valuation practice, and the medico-legal assessment has to be framed in the categories Italian law uses. Evidence held in Italy, such as the criminal file and the police reconstruction, must still be obtained.
Many serious claims are resolved before any court is seised, in negotiation with the insurer or its claims representative. In that phase, what counts is that the claim is presented and valued as an Italian court would value it: that is the benchmark the insurer uses.
Questions we are often asked
Can a client domiciled in another Member State sue the Italian motor insurer at home?
Yes, as a rule: Articles 11(1)(b) and 13(2) of Brussels I bis, as interpreted in Odenbreit, allow a direct action against the insurer before the courts of the injured party’s domicile.
If we sue at home, will the home law apply?
Not normally. Under Article 4(1) of Rome II the law of the country where the damage occurred applies, unless both parties were habitually resident in the same country or the case is manifestly more closely connected with another country.
Which limitation period applies?
The one of the applicable law (Article 15(h) of Rome II). Under Italian law, damage caused by the circulation of vehicles is subject to a two-year period, longer if the fact is a criminal offence (Article 2947 of the Civil Code). See the guide on time limits.
Does the forum change the value of the claim?
If Italian law applies, the heads of damage and their valuation should be the same wherever the claim is heard, but the way evidence is taken, the costs regime and the court’s familiarity with Italian practice can make a real difference to the outcome.
Sources
- Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012 (Brussels I bis), Articles 4, 7(2), 10–16: EUR-Lex
- Regulation (EC) No 864/2007 (Rome II), Articles 3, 4, 15, 17, 18, 28 and Recital 33: EUR-Lex
- Regulation (EC) No 593/2008 (Rome I), Article 4: EUR-Lex
- Court of Justice, Case C-463/06, FBTO Schadeverzekeringen v Odenbreit, 13 December 2007: EUR-Lex
- Court of Justice, Case C-347/08, Vorarlberger Gebietskrankenkasse v WGV-Schwäbische Allgemeine Versicherungs AG, 17 September 2009: EUR-Lex
- Hague Convention of 4 May 1971 on the Law Applicable to Traffic Accidents: HCCH
- Private Insurance Code, Legislative Decree No 209/2005, Article 144; Law No 24/2017, Articles 7, 8 and 12; Civil Code, Article 2947: Normattiva
If your firm is assessing where and how to bring a claim with an Italian connection, tell us about the case. We reply personally, with a first view on jurisdiction, applicable law and the time limits already running.