Birth injuries and obstetric negligence in Italian law

Claims for injuries to mother and child during pregnancy and birth: causation, records, the role of guidelines and the valuation of lifelong damage.
Reading time: about 4 minutes

Injuries suffered by a child during pregnancy or birth produce some of the most serious and costly claims in medical liability. The damage is lifelong, the medical issues are complex, and the claim usually belongs both to the child and to the parents. Italian law also has distinctive rules on wrongful birth, which differ from those of many other systems. This guide sets out the main issues for a foreign firm assessing an obstetric claim with an Italian connection.

Typical cases

Obstetric claims usually concern failures in the monitoring of labour, such as a misread or interrupted cardiotocography trace; delays in performing a caesarean section; mismanagement of complications such as shoulder dystocia; inappropriate use of instruments or drugs; or errors in neonatal resuscitation. The resulting injuries include hypoxic-ischaemic brain injury and cerebral palsy, brachial plexus injuries and, for the mother, injuries of their own. Claims also arise from errors in prenatal diagnosis.

Liability and causation

The general rules of Law No 24/2017 apply: the hospital or clinic is liable in contract for the conduct of its staff and for its own organisation, while the doctors and midwives it employs are liable in tort. The claim is normally brought against the facility and its insurer, after the compulsory mediation or pre-action expert assessment.

Causation is the heart of these cases. The claimant must prove, on the balance of probabilities, that the injury was caused by the management of pregnancy or labour rather than by pre-existing or unavoidable factors. That requires a reconstruction minute by minute from the clinical records, the monitoring traces and the neonatal records, by experts in obstetrics, neonatology and neurology alongside the forensic doctor. The court-appointed panel under Article 15 of the Law must include specialists in the relevant discipline.

Under Article 5 of the Law, practitioners must follow recognised guidelines or, failing them, good clinical practice. Italian guidelines on intrapartum care and the international standards they draw on are often decisive in assessing whether monitoring and decisions were adequate.

The child’s damages

For a child with a severe brain injury, the heads of damage include biological damage at a very high percentage of permanent impairment, moral suffering, the loss of future earning capacity and, often the largest item, the cost of lifelong care, assistance, therapy, equipment and adaptation of the home. These must be built on a detailed life care plan and capitalised over the child’s life expectancy, which itself may be the subject of expert dispute.

The parents’ damages

Parents of a child with very severe injuries have claims in their own right for the radical alteration of family life, recognised by Italian case law alongside the loss of the relationship in fatal cases, as well as for any psychiatric injury of their own and for the economic consequences, such as giving up work to care for the child.

Wrongful birth

Where a doctor fails to diagnose a foetal anomaly, the parents may claim that they were deprived of the possibility of terminating the pregnancy within the conditions laid down by Law No 194/1978. In judgment No 25767 of 22 December 2015, the joint sections of the Court of Cassation held that the mother must prove that, if properly informed, she would have chosen to terminate the pregnancy, and that the legal conditions for doing so were met; this can be proved by presumptions. The same judgment held that the child has no claim of their own for having been born with a disability (so-called wrongful life).

Time limits for a child’s claim

Under Italian law, limitation is suspended during minority only while the child has no legal representative and for six months after one is appointed (Article 2942 of the Civil Code). Where the parents act as legal representatives, time runs, and the ten-year period against the facility starts from the moment the damage and its cause could be perceived. Waiting until the child comes of age is therefore not a safe strategy.

Settlement

A settlement on behalf of a minor requires the authorisation of the guardianship judge (Article 320 of the Civil Code). In catastrophic cases, the structure of the settlement, lump sum or annuity, and the protection of the funds for the child’s future needs deserve as much attention as the amount.

Questions we are often asked

The child was born in Italy but the family now lives abroad. Which law applies?

Italian law, as a rule: the contract of treatment and the tort are both connected with Italy under the Rome I and Rome II Regulations.

Can the child’s claim wait until adulthood?

No. Limitation runs against a minor who has a legal representative. The claim should be preserved by a written demand.

Is cost of care abroad recoverable?

Yes, if it reflects the child’s actual needs and circumstances, documented by experts and evidence of local costs.

Sources

If your clients are considering a birth injury claim in Italy, tell us about the case: we reply personally.

Written by
Picture of Avv. Roberta Scarpellini
Avv. Roberta Scarpellini

Member of the Milan Bar, leading Studio Legale Scarpellini. The firm handles only cases of serious personal injury and death, from road traffic collisions and medical liability, and works with law firms abroad on claims with an Italian connection. President of NEVRA ETS.

Avv. Roberta Scarpellini · Milan Bar · studioscarpellini.com

A note. This guide provides general information on Italian law, up to date at the date shown, and is not a substitute for advice on a specific case. References to legislation and case law are to the Italian texts unless stated otherwise.

Working on a case with an Italian connection?

Tell us about the case

Every enquiry is read personally. We reply with a first view on what can be done in Italy, which time limits apply and what your client should not sign. See how we work with foreign law firms.

More guides

Chat with us on WhatsApp