A patient can be harmed not only by a negligent treatment, but by a treatment they were never properly asked to accept. Italian law gives the right to informed consent constitutional standing and statutory form, and the Court of Cassation has clarified what a patient must prove when the duty to inform is breached. This guide explains the rules and the two distinct kinds of damage that a breach can cause.
The legal basis
The right to consent to medical treatment rests on Articles 2, 13 and 32 of the Italian Constitution. Law No 219 of 22 December 2017 gives it statutory form. Article 1 provides that no treatment may be started or continued without the free and informed consent of the person concerned, except in the cases provided by law, and that every person has the right to know their health conditions and to be informed in a complete, up-to-date and understandable way about the diagnosis, prognosis, benefits and risks of the proposed treatments, the possible alternatives and the consequences of refusing treatment.
Consent is documented in writing or, where the patient’s condition so requires, by video recording or other means, and is included in the medical record. A generic form signed by the patient does not prove that adequate information was given: what matters is the content of the information actually provided.
Two kinds of damage
In judgment No 28985 of 11 November 2019, one of the so-called San Martino judgments, the Court of Cassation distinguished the consequences of a breach of the duty to inform.
The first is damage to health. Where a treatment performed correctly nonetheless causes a harm that was a known risk and was not disclosed, the patient can recover for the harm to health only by proving that, had they been informed, they would have refused the treatment. Without that causal link, the harm would have occurred anyway.
The second is damage to the right to self-determination. Even where the patient would have accepted the treatment, the lack of information can cause a distinct harm: not being able to prepare, to seek a second opinion, to organise one’s life in view of the risks. This damage is compensable if it reaches a threshold of seriousness and is proved, also by presumptions.
Where the treatment was also performed negligently, the claim for the negligence and the claim for the lack of consent stand side by side.
Proving the hypothetical refusal
The patient bears the burden of proving that they would have refused the treatment. The proof can be given by presumptions: the seriousness of the risk not disclosed, the existence of reasonable alternatives, the patient’s known attitudes and previous choices. The court will assess what that particular patient, in the circumstances, would have done.
Particular situations
For minors and persons lacking capacity, consent is given by their legal representatives, taking into account the person’s wishes as far as possible (Article 3 of Law No 219/2017). In emergencies, the necessary treatment can be given without consent. Law No 219/2017 also governs advance treatment directives and shared care planning.
For foreign patients, language is a recurring issue. Information given in a language the patient does not fully understand does not satisfy the duty to inform, and the facility should be able to show how communication was ensured.
Questions we are often asked
Our client signed a consent form. Is the claim lost?
No. The form is evidence, but the question is whether the information actually given was adequate for that treatment and that patient.
The operation was performed correctly. Is there still a claim?
Possibly, for the undisclosed risk that materialised, if the client would have refused the operation, and in any case for the harm to self-determination if it is serious and proved.
Our client did not speak Italian.
The facility must show that the information was given in a way the patient could understand.
Sources
- Law No 219 of 22 December 2017, Articles 1 and 3: Normattiva
- Constitution of the Italian Republic, Articles 2, 13, 32: Senato della Repubblica
- Court of Cassation, Third Civil Section, judgment No 28985 of 11 November 2019: Corte di Cassazione
- Law No 24/2017: Normattiva
If your client was treated in Italy without adequate information, tell us about the case: we reply personally.