Heads of damage in Italian personal injury law: a guide for common law practitioners

Biological damage, moral suffering, personalisation, loss of earnings, future care and relatives’ claims: how Italian law organises and values damages, and what it does not award.
Reading time: about 8 minutes

Practitioners trained in common law systems are used to heads of damage such as pain, suffering and loss of amenity, loss of earnings and the cost of care. Italian law covers much of the same ground, but it organises it differently, values much of it through tables rather than comparable awards, and draws some lines in unexpected places. Presenting a claim under Italian law in common law categories is one of the surest ways to undervalue it.

This guide maps the Italian heads of damage in serious personal injury and fatal cases, explains how each is valued and points to the issues that most often arise when the victim lives abroad.

The basic structure: non-pecuniary and pecuniary damage

Italian law distinguishes between pecuniary damage (danno patrimoniale), recoverable under Articles 1223 and 2056 of the Civil Code, and non-pecuniary damage (danno non patrimoniale), recoverable under Article 2059 in the cases provided by law and whenever a constitutionally protected interest, such as health, is seriously harmed. In their joint judgments of 11 November 2008 (Nos 26972 to 26975), the Court of Cassation described non-pecuniary damage as a single category, to be compensated in full but without duplication.

Later case law, and the legislation on motor and medical claims, have refined that picture. Within non-pecuniary damage the courts now distinguish two aspects that must both be considered: the impairment of health and of daily life, which forensic medicine can measure, and the inner suffering, which it cannot. Current tables express them as separate components of a single figure.

Biological damage

Danno biologico is the impairment of a person’s psychological and physical integrity that can be assessed by forensic medicine, with its effect on daily activities and on the dynamic and relational aspects of life, irrespective of any effect on earnings (Articles 138 and 139 of the Private Insurance Code). It is the closest equivalent of loss of amenity, but it is assessed in a much more standardised way.

The forensic expert expresses the permanent impairment in percentage points of the whole person, and the temporary impairment in days, divided into total and partial periods. The court then applies a table that gives a monetary value to each point, decreasing with age and increasing more than proportionally with the severity of the impairment.

Moral suffering

Danno morale is the inner suffering caused by the injury: pain, anguish, fear, shame. Since the 2017 amendments to Articles 138 and 139 of the Private Insurance Code, the statutory tables include it as a separate increase on the value of each point, and the Milan tables do the same. It must be alleged and proved, but proof may come from presumptions based on the nature of the injury and the circumstances of the accident.

Which table applies

For road traffic and medical liability claims, three regimes now coexist. Injuries of up to 9 points are valued under Article 139 of the Private Insurance Code. Injuries from 10 to 100 points are valued under the national table adopted by Presidential Decree No 12 of 13 January 2025, which applies to events after its entry into force on 5 March 2025. For earlier events and for other kinds of tort, the courts have traditionally used the tables of the Milan Civil Justice Observatory, treated as the national standard since the Court of Cassation’s judgment No 12408/2011 and now in their 2024 edition.

The boundary is moving. In judgment No 8630/2026 (filed on 7 April 2026, on a preliminary reference from the Tribunal of Milan), the Court of Cassation held that the national table applies directly only to road traffic, boat and medical liability claims, but is the preferred benchmark for the equitable valuation of biological damage, used indirectly and not by analogy, for events before 5 March 2025 and in other fields; a judge who departs from it must give specific reasons. An earlier judgment, No 11319/2025, had referred to such an indirect use only in passing. The point is still debated, and in any given case the choice of table can make a substantial difference: valuations should be run under both until the case law settles.

Personalisation

Table values reflect the ordinary consequences of an impairment for anyone of the same age. Where the injury has specific and exceptional consequences for the particular victim, the amount can be increased. The increase is capped by statute in motor and medical claims, and must be pleaded and proved with concrete facts: a sport practised at a high level, an artistic or professional skill lost, a life plan made impossible. Consequences that anyone with the same impairment would suffer are already in the table.

Psychological injury

A psychiatric condition caused by the accident, such as post-traumatic stress disorder or major depression, is part of biological damage if it is clinically diagnosed and assessed by the forensic expert, usually with the help of a psychiatrist. It is distinct from moral suffering, which needs no diagnosis. In fatal cases, a relative who develops a psychiatric condition after the death can claim it in addition to the loss of the family relationship.

Pecuniary losses

Pecuniary damage covers the loss suffered (danno emergente) and the gain lost (lucro cessante). The first includes medical and rehabilitation expenses, travel, care and assistance, aids and the adaptation of the home and vehicle; the second, earnings lost during recovery and the reduction of future earning capacity.

Italian courts distinguish between generic working capacity, the ability to work in general, which is part of biological damage, and specific working capacity, the ability to carry on the victim’s actual job, whose reduction is a pecuniary loss. A high percentage of impairment does not by itself prove a loss of income: the forensic expert must assess the effect on the specific job, and the loss must be shown with tax and employment records. The value of domestic work is also recognised, even for a person without income.

Future losses are usually calculated by capitalising an annual amount. The Milan Observatory publishes a table of coefficients for the early capitalisation of an annuity, based on life expectancy and an interest rate; courts may also award an annuity instead of a lump sum (Article 2057 of the Civil Code).

Future care

For catastrophic injuries the cost of care and assistance is often the largest item of the claim. It must be built from the ground up: the forensic and clinical experts define the needs, and the costs are documented with quotes, contracts and, where the victim lives abroad, evidence of costs in the country of residence. Recital 33 of the Rome II Regulation invites the court to take those actual costs into account in road traffic cases.

Damage suffered by relatives

When the victim dies, or survives with very severe injuries, close relatives have claims in their own right: the loss or radical alteration of the family relationship, valued with points-based tables; any psychiatric injury of their own; and the loss of financial support. Heirs can also claim, by inheritance, the rights acquired by the victim before death, such as terminal damage. The guide on fatal claims covers these in detail.

What Italian law does not award

Italian law is compensatory. There are no punitive or aggravated damages in domestic cases, although the joint sections of the Court of Cassation (judgment No 16601/2017) held that foreign punitive damages awards are not, as such, contrary to Italian public policy. The instantaneous loss of life is not compensated as such to the heirs (joint sections, judgment No 15350/2015). Benefits received from bodies that have a right of recovery against the wrongdoer, such as the Italian work-injury insurer INAIL, are deducted from the damages, while a survivor’s pension, for which no recovery mechanism exists, is not (joint sections, judgments Nos 12564 to 12567/2018).

Interest and revaluation

Damages in tort are a debt of value: they are calculated at current values on the date of judgment, and compensatory interest is added for the delay in payment, calculated on the amount progressively revalued (Court of Cassation, joint sections, judgment No 1712/1995). In a claim that lasts several years, this is a significant addition.

Questions we are often asked

Is there a cap on non-pecuniary damages?

Not as such, but the tables set the values, and personalisation is capped by statute in motor and medical claims. The total is driven by the percentage of impairment, the victim’s age and the proof of exceptional consequences.

Can we use our own country’s figures for care costs?

Care costs are pecuniary losses and should reflect the victim’s actual circumstances, including where they live. Non-pecuniary damage, by contrast, is valued with Italian tables when Italian law applies.

Are the experts’ percentages negotiable?

They are the most contested figures in any claim. The insurer’s forensic assessment is a starting point for negotiation, not a finding; an independent assessment is essential.

Sources

  • Civil Code, Articles 1223, 1226, 2056, 2057, 2059: Normattiva
  • Private Insurance Code, Articles 138 and 139: Normattiva
  • Presidential Decree No 12 of 13 January 2025: Normattiva
  • Osservatorio sulla Giustizia civile di Milano, Tabelle milanesi, Edizione 2024: Tribunale di Milano
  • Court of Cassation, joint sections, judgments Nos 26972–26975/2008, No 15350/2015, No 16601/2017, Nos 12564–12567/2018, No 1712/1995; Third Civil Section, judgments No 12408/2011, No 11319/2025, No 8630/2026: Corte di Cassazione
  • Regulation (EC) No 864/2007 (Rome II), Recital 33: EUR-Lex

If your firm needs an Italian valuation of a serious injury claim, tell us about the case. We reply personally, with a first view of the heads of damage and the table that applies.

Written by
Picture of Avv. Roberta Scarpellini
Avv. Roberta Scarpellini

Member of the Milan Bar, leading Studio Legale Scarpellini. The firm handles only cases of serious personal injury and death, from road traffic collisions and medical liability, and works with law firms abroad on claims with an Italian connection. President of NEVRA ETS.

Avv. Roberta Scarpellini · Milan Bar · studioscarpellini.com

A note. This guide provides general information on Italian law, up to date at the date shown, and is not a substitute for advice on a specific case. References to legislation and case law are to the Italian texts unless stated otherwise.

Working on a case with an Italian connection?

Tell us about the case

Every enquiry is read personally. We reply with a first view on what can be done in Italy, which time limits apply and what your client should not sign. See how we work with foreign law firms.

More guides

Chat with us on WhatsApp