Cross-border road accidents raise two different questions about insurance. When a foreign-registered vehicle causes an accident in Italy, who answers for it on Italian soil? And when a foreign resident is injured in Italy by an Italian vehicle, can they deal with the insurer from home? The European system answers both through the Green Card system, the national insurers’ bureaux, claims representatives and compensation bodies. This guide explains who does what, and how a claim moves between them.
Foreign vehicles in Italy: the UCI
Under the Green Card system and Articles 125 and 126 of the Private Insurance Code, the Italian Motor Insurers’ Bureau (Ufficio Centrale Italiano, UCI) handles and settles claims for accidents caused in Italy by vehicles registered abroad and normally based in a country of the system, as if they were insured in Italy. In practice the UCI often entrusts the handling to a correspondent appointed by the foreign insurer. For vehicles from the European Economic Area and other countries that apply the multilateral agreement between bureaux, the registration plate itself is evidence of insurance, and no green card is required.
The claim follows the Italian procedure: a written claim with the content required by Article 148, the same deadlines, the same direct action, and Italian rules on the valuation of damages. If the foreign vehicle turns out to be uninsured, or comes from a country outside the system, the Road Victims Guarantee Fund may intervene instead.
Foreign victims of Italian vehicles: claims representatives
Directive 2009/103/EC, which codified the earlier Motor Insurance Directives and was amended by Directive (EU) 2021/2118, gives victims resident in a Member State who are injured in another Member State a way to deal with the claim from home. Each motor insurer must appoint, in every Member State other than the one where it is authorised, a claims representative responsible for handling and settling such claims (Article 21). Within three months of the claim, the insurer or its representative must make a reasoned offer of compensation where liability is not disputed and the damages have been quantified, or give a reasoned reply to the points made in the claim (Article 22).
To find the right insurer and representative, each Member State has an information centre (Article 23); in Italy the function is performed through CONSAP. The victim can ask the information centre of their own country for the details of the insurer of the vehicle at fault and of its representative.
Compensation bodies
If the insurer or its claims representative fails to make a reasoned offer or reply within three months, or the insurer has not appointed a representative, the victim may apply to the compensation body of their own Member State (Article 24), provided they have not already brought proceedings directly against the insurer. The body then recovers from the compensation body of the insurer’s Member State. The same bodies intervene when the vehicle or the insurer cannot be identified within two months (Article 25), in which case the compensation is ultimately borne by the guarantee fund of the country of the accident.
Which law decides the amount
The claims representative is only an intermediary: it does not change the applicable law. For an accident in Italy, Italian law will normally govern liability and damages under Article 4(1) of the Rome II Regulation, and the offer should be assessed against Italian heads of damage and Italian tables. Claimants and their lawyers abroad sometimes evaluate the representative’s offer against the standards of their own country, with misleading results in either direction.
Choosing the route
Three routes are open to a victim resident in another Member State: negotiating with the claims representative at home; suing the Italian insurer at home under the Brussels I bis Regulation, following Odenbreit; or claiming and, if necessary, suing in Italy. They can be combined. What matters is that the claim is valued as an Italian court would value it and that limitation is interrupted in time.
Questions we are often asked
An Austrian truck caused the accident in Italy. Whom do we claim from?
From the UCI or the correspondent of the Austrian insurer in Italy, under the Italian procedure. The victim can also claim against the Austrian insurer directly.
The claims representative has not replied after three months.
The victim can apply to the compensation body of their own Member State under Article 24 of Directive 2009/103/EC, and can at any time pursue the insurer directly.
Does dealing with the representative stop limitation?
A written claim to the insurer or its representative should interrupt Italian limitation, but the safest course is to send the demand to the insurer itself as well.
Sources
- Directive 2009/103/EC, Articles 20–26: EUR-Lex
- Private Insurance Code, Articles 125, 126, 148: Normattiva
- Council of Bureaux (Green Card system): cobx.org
- CONSAP – information centre and guarantee funds: consap.it
- Regulation (EC) No 864/2007 (Rome II), Article 4: EUR-Lex
If your client was injured in Italy, or by a foreign vehicle in Italy, tell us about the case: we reply personally.