When someone dies in Italy and the family lives abroad, the first weeks bring decisions that cannot wait and are difficult to make from a distance: whether to attend the autopsy, how to bring the body home, which documents to obtain, what to say to the insurer. Some of these decisions have legal consequences that will last for the whole claim. This guide sets out what usually happens and what a foreign firm advising the family should make sure is done.
The judicial authority and the autopsy
A death on the road, or a death in hospital in suspicious circumstances, is reported to the public prosecutor, who opens an investigation and often orders an autopsy. Because an autopsy is a technical examination that cannot be repeated, the injured parties, including the close relatives, must be notified and can appoint their own expert to attend and make observations (Article 360 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The notice period is short. Appointing a forensic doctor of the family’s choice at this stage can be decisive both for the criminal case and for any civil claim, particularly in medical deaths.
Release and repatriation of the body
The body is released for burial or transport once the judicial authority has given its authorisation. International transport of remains is governed by the Italian rules on mortuary police (Presidential Decree No 285/1990) and by the international agreements applicable to the destination country, and requires a mortuary passport or equivalent authorisation. Funeral directors with international experience and the family’s consulate usually coordinate the formalities. Repatriation and funeral costs are recoverable from the liable party and should be documented.
Documents
The family will need the death certificate and, for use in other Member States, can rely on Regulation (EU) 2016/1191, which dispenses with legalisation and apostille between Member States and allows a multilingual standard form to be attached as a translation aid. The heirs will need to prove their status, which in cross-border successions can be done with the European Certificate of Succession under Regulation (EU) No 650/2012. For the claim, the accident report reference, the details of the vehicles and insurers involved and, in medical cases, the full clinical record should be requested at once.
The insurer
Insurers sometimes contact families soon after a death, with condolences and, at times, with forms or proposals. Nothing should be signed before the family has been advised. A written claim to the insurer under Article 148 of the Private Insurance Code, stating the family relationships, starts the statutory procedure and interrupts limitation.
Preserving evidence
Evidence on liability is held mainly by the authorities: the police reconstruction, witness statements, recordings, the vehicles. The family’s lawyer can follow the investigation as an injured party and ask for specific steps. Vehicles should not be scrapped until they have been examined. Witnesses known to the family should be identified while memories are fresh. In medical cases, the clinical record should be obtained before anything else.
Limitation
For deaths caused by vehicles, the civil limitation period is two years, extended where the facts constitute a criminal offence; for medical deaths, ten years against the facility and five against the practitioner (Articles 2946 and 2947 of the Civil Code; Article 7 of Law No 24/2017). A written demand interrupts limitation and should be sent early, by or on behalf of every relative with a claim.
What to tell the family
A family abroad needs, above all, to know what is happening and what is expected of them. A short written explanation of the criminal investigation, the role of the autopsy, the timing of the release of the body and the steps of the claim, in their language, prevents misunderstandings and protects their rights.
Questions we are often asked
The prosecutor has ordered an autopsy. Must the family attend?
No, but they can appoint an expert to attend on their behalf. In most cases it is advisable.
Who pays for repatriation?
The family initially; the costs are then recoverable from the liable party or its insurer and should be documented.
The insurer has sent a form to sign. What should the family do?
Not sign anything until they have been advised.
Sources
- Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 360: Normattiva
- Presidential Decree No 285 of 10 September 1990 (mortuary police regulations): Normattiva
- Regulation (EU) 2016/1191 on public documents: EUR-Lex
- Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 on succession: EUR-Lex
- Private Insurance Code, Article 148: Normattiva
- Civil Code, Articles 2946 and 2947; Law No 24/2017, Article 7: Normattiva
If you are assisting a family in the first weeks after a death in Italy, tell us about the case: we reply personally.