Mediation or pre-action expert assessment? Choosing the compulsory route in medical claims

The two routes required by Article 8 of Law No 24/2017 compared: timing, costs, the value of the expert report and the 90-day deadline that follows.
Reading time: about 4 minutes

Before a medical liability claim can be brought before an Italian court, the claimant must attempt one of two procedures: mediation or a pre-action expert assessment before the court. Article 8 of Law No 24/2017 makes the attempt a condition for proceeding, and lets the claimant choose. The choice is one of the first strategic decisions in an Italian medical claim, and it shapes timing, costs and the evidence on which any settlement will rest.

Under Article 8(1) of Law No 24/2017, anyone who intends to bring a claim for damages arising from medical liability must first file an application for a pre-action technical assessment under Article 696-bis of the Code of Civil Procedure. Article 8(2) allows the claimant instead to attempt mediation under Legislative Decree No 28/2010, which in turn lists medical and healthcare liability among the matters subject to compulsory mediation (Article 5). The two routes are alternatives: completing one satisfies the requirement.

All parties, including the insurers of the facility and of the practitioners, must take part. Under Article 8(4), a party who fails to participate without justification can be ordered, in the subsequent judgment, to pay the costs of the assessment and of the proceedings and a further sum determined by the court.

The pre-action expert assessment

The claimant files an application with the court. The judge appoints a panel of experts, which under Article 15 of the Law must include a forensic doctor and a specialist in the relevant discipline, and sets the questions. The experts examine the patient and the records, hear the parties’ own experts and attempt a settlement; if the parties agree, the agreement is recorded and becomes enforceable.

If no settlement is reached, the report is filed and can be used in the subsequent proceedings. The claim on the merits must then be started within 90 days of the filing of the report, using the simplified procedure; if it is, the effects of the original application on limitation and on the claim are preserved (Article 8(3)). The simplified procedure, formerly under Article 702-bis, is now governed by Articles 281-decies and following of the Code of Civil Procedure after the 2022 reform.

Mediation

Mediation takes place before an accredited mediation body, not a court. Since the 2022 reform of Legislative Decree No 28/2010, the parties must attend in person, assisted by lawyers, and may be represented only by a person with full knowledge of the facts and power to settle. The procedure has a set maximum duration, which the parties can extend by agreement. The application, once communicated to the other parties, has the same effect on limitation as a judicial claim (Article 8 of Legislative Decree No 28/2010).

Mediation does not produce a technical report by a court-appointed expert. The mediator can, with the parties’ agreement, appoint an expert, but the value of that opinion in later proceedings is more limited.

How to choose

The pre-action assessment is usually the stronger route in serious cases. It produces an independent technical assessment by a panel of the kind the court would appoint anyway; insurers tend to negotiate seriously only once such an assessment exists; and the report carries over into the proceedings, saving time. Its costs are higher, because the claimant normally advances the experts’ fees, and it takes longer.

Mediation can be appropriate where liability is clear and the dispute is mainly about the amount, where the facility or its insurer has already shown willingness to settle, or where a quick attempt is useful before investing in a court-appointed assessment.

In both cases, the claimant’s own medico-legal and specialist assessment should be prepared before the procedure starts. The panel’s questions are shaped by the application, and a well-documented medical case makes all the difference to the outcome.

Questions we are often asked

Can we skip both and sue directly?

No. The court will suspend the case and set a deadline for completing one of the two procedures.

Does the procedure interrupt limitation?

Yes. Both the application for a pre-action assessment and the mediation application have that effect, provided the subsequent steps are taken within the prescribed time.

Must our client travel to Italy?

For the assessment, the experts will usually need to examine the patient, and the client’s presence is normally required at least once. In mediation, the party may be represented by someone with full knowledge of the facts and power to settle.

Sources

  • Law No 24/2017, Articles 8 and 15: Normattiva
  • Code of Civil Procedure, Articles 281-decies and 696-bis: Normattiva
  • Legislative Decree No 28/2010, Articles 5, 6 and 8: Normattiva
  • Legislative Decree No 149/2022 (civil procedure reform): Normattiva

If your client is preparing a medical liability claim in Italy, tell us about the case: we reply personally.

Written by
Picture of Avv. Roberta Scarpellini
Avv. Roberta Scarpellini

Member of the Milan Bar, leading Studio Legale Scarpellini. The firm handles only cases of serious personal injury and death, from road traffic collisions and medical liability, and works with law firms abroad on claims with an Italian connection. President of NEVRA ETS.

Avv. Roberta Scarpellini · Milan Bar · studioscarpellini.com

A note. This guide provides general information on Italian law, up to date at the date shown, and is not a substitute for advice on a specific case. References to legislation and case law are to the Italian texts unless stated otherwise.

Working on a case with an Italian connection?

Tell us about the case

Every enquiry is read personally. We reply with a first view on what can be done in Italy, which time limits apply and what your client should not sign. See how we work with foreign law firms.

More guides

Chat with us on WhatsApp