When a person dies in Italy as a result of a road collision or a medical error, the family abroad faces at the same time a bereavement, an unfamiliar legal system and decisions that cannot wait: the autopsy, the release of the body, the first contacts with the insurer, the criminal investigation. This guide sets out the rights Italian law gives to the family, how they are valued and the steps that matter most in the first weeks, for a foreign firm advising relatives who live outside Italy.
Two kinds of claim
Relatives can claim in their own right (iure proprio) for the harm the death causes them personally, and as heirs (iure hereditatis) for the rights the victim acquired before dying. The distinction determines who can claim what. Rights in one’s own right belong to each relative, whatever the succession; inherited rights depend on who the heirs are, which, for a deceased habitually resident abroad, may be governed by the law of that country under Regulation (EU) No 650/2012.
Loss of the family relationship
The central claim of the family is for the loss of the family relationship (danno da perdita del rapporto parentale), a non-pecuniary damage that compensates the irreversible destruction of the bond with the deceased. It belongs to the spouse, children, parents and siblings, and can extend to grandparents, grandchildren and other relatives depending on the intensity of the relationship. Under Article 1(49) of Law No 76/2016, a de facto cohabiting partner is entitled to compensation on the same criteria as a surviving spouse.
Italian courts value this damage with tables. Following the Court of Cassation’s judgment No 10579/2021, which required a points-based method so that awards are transparent and comparable, the Milan Observatory adopted in 2022 an integrated points table, now in its 2024 edition. Points are awarded according to the age of the victim and of the relative, cohabitation, the number of surviving members of the family unit and the quality of the relationship. Each relative must allege and prove the bond; for the closest relatives it is presumed, but evidence of the actual relationship affects the valuation.
Psychiatric injury and pecuniary losses of the family
A relative who develops a diagnosed psychiatric condition after the death, such as a pathological grief reaction or major depression, has a separate claim for biological damage, assessed by a forensic expert with a psychiatrist. Relatives who depended financially on the deceased can claim the loss of that support, calculated on the income the deceased would have earned and the share devoted to the family, capitalised over the expected period of dependency. Funeral and repatriation expenses are recoverable.
Rights inherited from the victim
If the victim survived for an appreciable time before dying, they acquired a claim for the biological damage suffered in that period and, if conscious of the approaching end, for the anguish of that awareness. These claims pass to the heirs. The 2024 edition of the Milan tables includes specific criteria for this terminal damage. Italian law does not compensate the loss of life itself when death is instantaneous: the joint sections of the Court of Cassation (judgment No 15350/2015) excluded any inherited claim for the so-called danno tanatologico.
The criminal proceedings
A death on the road normally leads to an investigation for road homicide (Article 589-bis of the Criminal Code); a death in hospital may lead to an investigation for negligent homicide (Article 589), with the specific rules of Article 590-sexies for healthcare professionals. The family are injured parties from the start. When the prosecutor orders technical examinations that cannot be repeated, such as an autopsy, the injured parties must be notified and may appoint their own expert to attend (Article 360 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). For a family abroad, this is often the first urgent decision, and it is taken within days.
At trial, the family can join as civil parties and ask for compensation, including an interim award. The evidence gathered in the criminal proceedings, from the accident reconstruction to the autopsy report, is usually decisive for the civil claim as well.
The claim to the insurer
In road traffic deaths the claim is made to the insurer of the vehicle at fault under Article 148 of the Private Insurance Code, setting out the family relationships, the circumstances of each relative and the documents that prove them. Each relative’s position is valued separately, and each must sign their own release. Settlements on behalf of minor children require the authorisation of the guardianship judge (Article 320 of the Civil Code).
For deaths caused by a medical error, the claim is made to the healthcare facility and its insurer, after the compulsory mediation or pre-action expert assessment required by Article 8 of Law No 24/2017.
The first weeks
For a foreign family, the practical issues come first: the release of the body after the judicial authority’s authorisation, repatriation, death certificates and their translation, the identification of the heirs. Behind them are decisions with legal consequences: appointing an expert for the autopsy, requesting the accident report and the medical records, sending a demand to the insurer that interrupts limitation, and avoiding any signature on documents the insurer may propose before the family has been advised.
Questions we are often asked
Which relatives can claim?
The spouse or civil partner, children, parents and siblings as a rule; a de facto cohabiting partner on the same criteria as a spouse; grandparents, grandchildren and other relatives where they prove a significant relationship with the deceased.
Does it matter that the family lives abroad?
Not for the existence of the claims, which follow Italian law when the death occurred in Italy. It matters for the evidence of the relationship, for the costs of repatriation and travel, and for the identification of the heirs.
The death was instantaneous. Is there any inherited claim?
Not for the loss of life as such. The family’s claims in their own right, for the loss of the relationship, any psychiatric injury and the loss of support, are unaffected.
Sources
- Civil Code, Articles 320, 1223, 2043, 2056, 2059: Normattiva
- Law No 76 of 20 May 2016, Article 1(49): Normattiva
- Criminal Code, Articles 589, 589-bis, 590-sexies; Code of Criminal Procedure, Articles 74 and 360: Normattiva
- Private Insurance Code, Article 148; Law No 24/2017, Article 8: Normattiva
- Osservatorio sulla Giustizia civile di Milano, Tabelle milanesi, Edizione 2024 (loss of the family relationship and terminal damage): Tribunale di Milano
- Court of Cassation, Third Civil Section, judgment No 10579/2021; joint sections, judgment No 15350/2015: Corte di Cassazione
- Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 on succession: EUR-Lex
If your firm is assisting a family after a death in Italy, tell us about the case. We reply personally, with the steps that cannot wait.