Medical liability in Italy was reorganised by Law No 24 of 8 March 2017, known as the Gelli-Bianco Law after its sponsors. It changed the nature of the liability of doctors, made a pre-action step compulsory, gave patients a direct action against insurers and tied the valuation of damage to the motor insurance tables. For a foreign firm whose client was harmed during treatment in Italy, as a tourist, a resident or a cross-border patient, these rules decide whom to claim against, how quickly to act and what evidence to secure first.
Two kinds of liability
Under Article 7(1) of the Law, the public or private healthcare facility is liable in contract, under Articles 1218 and 1228 of the Civil Code, for the negligent or wilful conduct of the professionals it uses, including those who are not its employees. Under Article 7(3), the professional employed by or working within the facility is liable in tort, under Article 2043, unless they acted on the basis of a contractual obligation undertaken with the patient.
The distinction has two practical consequences. The first is the limitation period: ten years against the facility (Article 2946 of the Civil Code), five years against the practitioner in tort (Article 2947(1)). The second is the burden of proof. In contract, the patient must prove the treatment relationship, the worsening of their health or the onset of a new condition, and the causal link with the treatment; the facility must then prove that it performed correctly or that the outcome was due to a cause it could not foresee or avoid. The Court of Cassation clarified this allocation in its judgments of 11 November 2019 (among them No 28991/2019), insisting that the causal link remains for the patient to prove, on the balance of probabilities.
In practice, claims are brought against the facility and its insurer. Many public health authorities manage their risks through self-insurance, wholly or in part, which affects who handles the claim.
Securing the medical records
The full clinical record is the backbone of the claim. Article 4(2) of the Law requires the facility to provide the patient, or those entitled, with a copy of the medical documentation within seven days of the request, with any additions within thirty days. Requests should be made at once, and the copies checked for completeness: nursing records, anaesthesia charts, consent forms, imaging and laboratory results are often missing from a first delivery.
The compulsory pre-action step
Before suing, the claimant must attempt one of two procedures (Article 8). The first is a pre-action expert assessment before the court under Article 696-bis of the Code of Civil Procedure, in which a court-appointed panel examines the case and attempts a settlement. The second is mediation under Legislative Decree No 28/2010. The choice is strategic. The pre-action assessment produces a technical report that can be used in subsequent proceedings and often drives settlement; mediation is quicker to start but depends on the parties’ willingness to negotiate.
If the pre-action assessment does not lead to a settlement, the claim on the merits must be started within 90 days of the filing of the expert report, so that the effects of the original application are preserved (Article 8(3)). All parties, including insurers, are required to take part in the procedure.
The court-appointed experts
Article 15 requires the court to entrust the technical assessment to a panel composed of a forensic doctor and a specialist in the discipline concerned, chosen from official registers. The quality of the medical case put to that panel, through the claimant’s own experts, is often what determines the outcome.
Guidelines and good practice
Article 5 requires healthcare professionals to follow the recommendations in officially recognised guidelines or, failing those, good clinical practice. Compliance is relevant in criminal proceedings, where Article 590-sexies of the Criminal Code limits liability for lack of skill when the appropriate guidelines were followed, and in civil proceedings, where the judge takes the practitioner’s conduct into account when determining the damages (Article 7(3)).
Insurance and the direct action
Facilities and practitioners must be insured or adopt equivalent measures (Article 10). Article 12 gives the injured party a direct action against the facility’s insurer, which became operative once the implementing ministerial decree on minimum insurance requirements, Decree No 232 of 2023, entered into force in 2024. Article 13 requires the facility and the insurer to notify the practitioner of the claim, which matters for any later recovery action against them.
Valuing the damage
Article 7(4) applies to medical liability the tables of Articles 138 and 139 of the Private Insurance Code. For injuries of up to 9 points this means the statutory micro-injury values; for injuries from 10 to 100 points, the national table of Presidential Decree No 12/2025. The application of the national table to events before its entry into force on 5 March 2025 has been debated. In judgment No 8630/2026 (filed on 7 April 2026, on a preliminary reference from the Tribunal of Milan), the Court of Cassation held that the national table applies directly only to road traffic, boat and medical liability claims, but is the preferred benchmark for the equitable valuation of biological damage, used indirectly and not by analogy, for events before 5 March 2025 and in other fields; a judge who departs from it must give specific reasons. An earlier judgment, No 11319/2025, had referred to such an indirect use only in passing. Pecuniary losses, future care and, in fatal cases, the losses of relatives are valued as in any personal injury claim.
Informed consent
Law No 219 of 22 December 2017 sets out the patient’s right to be informed and to consent to treatment. A breach of the duty to inform is a separate wrong: the patient can recover for the harm to self-determination if they prove they would have refused the treatment had they been properly informed, or for the health consequences of a risk that materialised without having been disclosed.
Questions we are often asked
Our client was treated in Italy as a tourist. Does Italian law apply?
In almost all cases. Under Rome I (Article 4(1)(b)) the contract of treatment is governed by the law of the provider’s habitual residence, and under Rome II (Article 4(1)) the tort is governed by the law of the place where the damage occurred, both pointing to Italy.
Should we claim against the doctor or the hospital?
Usually against the facility and its insurer: the facility is liable in contract, with a longer limitation period and a more favourable burden of proof for the patient, and answers for the conduct of its staff.
Mediation or pre-action expert assessment?
It depends on the case. Where the medical issues are complex and the insurer is unlikely to negotiate without a technical assessment, the pre-action expert assessment is generally the stronger route.
How soon must we act?
Limitation is ten years against the facility and five against the practitioner, but medical records and witness memories deteriorate quickly. Request the records at once.
Sources
- Law No 24 of 8 March 2017, Articles 4, 5, 7, 8, 10, 12, 13, 15: Normattiva
- Law No 219 of 22 December 2017 on informed consent: Normattiva
- Civil Code, Articles 1218, 1228, 2043, 2946, 2947; Code of Civil Procedure, Article 696-bis; Criminal Code, Article 590-sexies: Normattiva
- Legislative Decree No 28 of 4 March 2010 on mediation: Normattiva
- Presidential Decree No 12 of 13 January 2025: Normattiva
- Court of Cassation, Third Civil Section, judgment No 28991 of 11 November 2019; judgment No 8630 of 7 April 2026: Corte di Cassazione
If your client was harmed during treatment in Italy, tell us about the case. We reply personally, with a first view on the route to follow and the records to request now.