Italy has a compulsory motor insurance system, a statutory claims procedure and, for serious injuries, a national table of values. On paper the path from accident to compensation is well marked. In practice, a serious claim is won or lost on the quality of three things: the evidence on liability, the medico-legal assessment and the way the claim is presented to the insurer within the statutory framework.
This guide follows a serious road traffic claim from the accident to its conclusion, with an eye to the issues that arise when the victim lives abroad.
Compulsory insurance and who answers for the damage
Every motor vehicle circulating in Italy must be insured for third-party liability (Article 122 of the Private Insurance Code), up to minimum amounts set by Article 128 and periodically adjusted in line with Directive 2009/103/EC. The insurer of the vehicle at fault is the natural counterparty of the claim, and the injured party can sue it directly (Article 144).
Under the Civil Code, the driver is liable unless they prove they did everything possible to avoid the damage (Article 2054(1)); in a collision between vehicles each driver is presumed equally at fault until the contrary is proved (Article 2054(2)); and the owner is jointly liable with the driver unless the vehicle was used against their will (Article 2054(3)). These presumptions shape the negotiation: the burden of disproving them falls on the party they weigh against.
Passengers are in a privileged position. Article 141 of the Private Insurance Code allows a third-party passenger to claim from the insurer of the vehicle in which they were travelling, whatever the allocation of fault between the drivers, except for unforeseeable circumstances. The insurer then recovers from the insurer of the vehicle at fault.
The first weeks: preserving the evidence
After a serious accident the police or Carabinieri draw up a report, take measurements and photographs and, in cases of death or serious injury, inform the public prosecutor. If the facts may constitute road homicide or serious road injury (Articles 589-bis and 590-bis of the Criminal Code), a criminal investigation opens, and with it the most important source of evidence on liability: the official reconstruction, witness statements, any recordings, the examination of the vehicles.
For a victim abroad, these documents are in Italian and in Italy. Access to the criminal file depends on the stage of the investigation; the injured party can appoint a lawyer to take part, and when the prosecutor orders technical examinations that cannot be repeated, such as an autopsy or an examination of the vehicles, the injured party must be notified and can appoint its own expert (Article 360 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). Acting early is often decisive.
The claim to the insurer
The claim formally starts with a written request to the insurer under Article 148 of the Private Insurance Code. For personal injury it must contain, among other things, the age, occupation and income of the injured person, a description of the injuries and, once they have stabilised, a medical certificate of recovery with or without permanent effects. The insurer then has 90 days to make a reasoned offer or to explain why it will not (Article 148(2)).
The request is also a condition for suing: an action against the insurer cannot be brought until the statutory period has expired (Article 145). In addition, before going to court, the claimant must invite the other side to an assisted negotiation (Article 3 of Decree-Law No 132/2014). Mandatory mediation does not apply to road traffic claims.
The direct compensation procedure (indennizzo diretto, Article 149), in which the victim claims from their own insurer, applies only to collisions between two identified and insured vehicles and, for drivers, to injuries of up to 9 points of permanent impairment. It is not the route for serious injuries.
Waiting for the injuries to stabilise
The value of a personal injury claim depends on the permanent impairment, which can only be assessed once the clinical picture has stabilised. Insurers sometimes make early offers; accepting them before the stabilisation of the injuries, and before an independent medico-legal assessment, is one of the most common and costly mistakes. Where the client needs money in the meantime, a payment on account can be negotiated without closing the claim.
The medico-legal assessment and the valuation
The insurer will have the victim examined by its own forensic doctor. The claimant should be assessed by an independent forensic expert, assisted where needed by a specialist, who will express the temporary impairment in days, the permanent impairment in percentage points and the need for future care.
The non-pecuniary damage is then valued with statutory tables: Article 139 of the Private Insurance Code for injuries of up to 9 points; for injuries from 10 to 100 points, the national table of Presidential Decree No 12/2025, in force for accidents after 5 March 2025. Pecuniary losses, past and future, are added: medical and care expenses, loss of earnings, loss of earning capacity, adaptation of the home and vehicle. The guide on heads of damage examines each item.
When the vehicle is foreign, uninsured or unknown
If the vehicle at fault is registered abroad, the claim is handled in Italy by the Italian Motor Insurers’ Bureau (UCI) under the Green Card system (Articles 125 and 126 of the Private Insurance Code). If it is uninsured or cannot be identified, the Road Victims Guarantee Fund intervenes (Article 283). A victim resident in another Member State injured in Italy by an Italian-insured vehicle can deal with the insurer’s claims representative in their own country (Articles 21 and 22 of Directive 2009/103/EC).
Settlement or litigation
Most serious claims settle, but the settlement reflects the strength of the case the insurer would face in court. If the offer is inadequate, the claim proceeds after the assisted negotiation, before the civil court or, where the facts are an offence, within the criminal proceedings through a civil-party claim. In court, a court-appointed expert will assess the injuries again, and the claimant’s party expert takes part in that assessment.
Questions we are often asked
Our client was a passenger. Does fault between the drivers matter?
Not for the claim against the insurer of the vehicle in which the client was travelling: Article 141 of the Private Insurance Code allows the passenger to recover from it regardless of the allocation of fault, save for unforeseeable circumstances.
Our client was partly at fault. Is the claim lost?
No. Compensation is reduced in proportion to the client’s share of fault and its consequences (Article 1227 of the Civil Code). Not wearing a seat belt or helmet is a typical ground for reduction, and its causal weight must be proved.
How long does the client have to claim?
Two years from the accident for damage caused by vehicles, longer if the fact is a criminal offence (Article 2947 of the Civil Code). A written demand interrupts the period. See the guide on time limits.
Can medical expenses incurred abroad be recovered?
Yes, if they are a consequence of the accident and are documented. Where a public health system has covered them, it may itself have a recovery claim against the insurer.
Sources
- Private Insurance Code, Legislative Decree No 209/2005, Articles 122, 125, 126, 128, 138, 139, 141, 144, 145, 148, 149, 283: Normattiva
- Civil Code, Articles 1227, 2054, 2947: Normattiva
- Criminal Code, Articles 589-bis and 590-bis; Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 360: Normattiva
- Decree-Law No 132/2014, Article 3: Normattiva
- Presidential Decree No 12 of 13 January 2025 (national table for injuries of 10 to 100 points): Normattiva
- Directive 2009/103/EC, Articles 21–24: EUR-Lex
If your firm is handling a serious road traffic claim with an Italian connection, tell us about the case. We reply personally, with a first view on liability, valuation and the next steps in Italy.