Pedestrians, cyclists and passengers: liability rules under Article 2054 of the Civil Code

Presumptions of liability, the driver’s burden of proof and the special position of passengers under Article 141 of the Private Insurance Code.
Reading time: about 5 minutes

The most seriously injured victims of road accidents in Italy are often not drivers: they are pedestrians, cyclists and passengers. Italian law treats them in different ways. Pedestrians and passengers benefit from rules that put the burden of proof on the driver or give them a claim regardless of fault; cyclists are drivers of vehicles and share the presumptions that apply between vehicles. This guide sets out the rules and the points of dispute that most often decide these cases.

The basic rule: Article 2054 of the Civil Code

The driver of a vehicle not running on rails is liable for damage caused to persons or property by its circulation, unless they prove that they did everything possible to avoid the damage (Article 2054(1)). This is a reversal of the ordinary burden of proof in tort: the injured person must prove the accident and the causal link, while the driver must prove that the accident was unavoidable for them.

In a collision between vehicles, each driver is presumed to have contributed equally to the damage suffered by each vehicle, unless the contrary is proved (Article 2054(2)). The owner, or the usufructuary or purchaser under reservation of title, is jointly liable with the driver unless they prove that the vehicle was used against their will (Article 2054(3)). In all cases, the persons liable also answer for damage caused by defects in the construction or maintenance of the vehicle (Article 2054(4)).

Pedestrians

A pedestrian struck by a vehicle need only prove the accident and the injury; the driver must prove that they did everything possible to avoid it. Italian case law requires drivers to anticipate a degree of imprudence by pedestrians, especially near crossings, schools and in urban areas. The driver is exonerated entirely only where the pedestrian’s conduct was so sudden and unforeseeable that the collision could not be avoided.

More often, the pedestrian’s conduct, such as crossing outside a pedestrian crossing, at night in dark clothing or against a red light, leads to a reduction of compensation for contributory fault under Article 1227 of the Civil Code. The apportionment is a matter for the evidence, and the official reconstruction in the criminal proceedings is usually decisive.

Cyclists

Bicycles are vehicles under the Highway Code (Article 47 of Legislative Decree No 285/1992), and cyclists must respect the rules of the road. In a collision between a bicycle and a car, the presumption of equal fault in Article 2054(2) applies unless either party proves the other’s exclusive fault. Pedal-assisted bicycles within the legal limits, a continuous rated power of 0.25 kW with assistance cut off at 25 km/h or when the cyclist stops pedalling, are treated as bicycles (Article 50).

Bicycles are not subject to compulsory third-party insurance. When a cyclist is injured by a motor vehicle, the claim is made against the motor insurer in the usual way. When a cyclist injures a pedestrian, the claim depends on whether the cyclist has a liability policy, often included in household insurance. The 2024 reform of the Highway Code (Law No 177/2024) introduced an identification plate and compulsory third-party insurance for electric scooters, which became operative after implementing measures adopted in 2026.

Passengers

Passengers are in the most favourable position. Under Article 141 of the Private Insurance Code, a third-party passenger injured in an accident is compensated by the insurer of the vehicle in which they were travelling, regardless of how fault is allocated between the drivers involved, unless the accident was due to an unforeseeable event (caso fortuito). The insurer then recovers, where appropriate, from the insurer of the vehicle at fault. Passengers can alternatively claim against the insurer of the other vehicle.

Family members travelling in the car are third parties for personal injury purposes: only the driver who caused the accident is excluded from cover for their own injuries (Article 129). A passenger who accepted a lift from a driver they knew to be drunk may see compensation reduced for contributory fault, but the claim against the insurer remains.

Seat belts and helmets

Not wearing a seat belt or a helmet does not exclude the claim, but it can reduce compensation if it contributed to the severity of the injuries (Article 1227(1) of the Civil Code). The insurer must prove the omission and its causal weight, usually through a medico-legal and biomechanical analysis. The reductions applied in practice vary widely and are a frequent object of negotiation.

Questions we are often asked

Our client was struck on a pedestrian crossing. Can the driver blame them?

Only with difficulty. The driver must prove that they did everything possible to avoid the collision, and drivers are required to give way at crossings.

Our client was cycling and was hit by a car. Is fault presumed equal?

Under Article 2054(2) the presumption of equal fault applies between vehicles, including bicycles, but it yields to proof of how the accident actually happened.

Our client was a passenger in a car driven by a relative.

The relative’s insurer must compensate the passenger under Article 141 of the Private Insurance Code, regardless of fault, and family members are covered as third parties for personal injury.

Sources

  • Civil Code, Articles 1227 and 2054: Normattiva
  • Private Insurance Code, Articles 129 and 141: Normattiva
  • Highway Code, Legislative Decree No 285/1992: Normattiva

If your client was injured in Italy as a pedestrian, cyclist or passenger, tell us about the case: we reply personally.

Written by
Picture of Avv. Roberta Scarpellini
Avv. Roberta Scarpellini

Member of the Milan Bar, leading Studio Legale Scarpellini. The firm handles only cases of serious personal injury and death, from road traffic collisions and medical liability, and works with law firms abroad on claims with an Italian connection. President of NEVRA ETS.

Avv. Roberta Scarpellini · Milan Bar · studioscarpellini.com

A note. This guide provides general information on Italian law, up to date at the date shown, and is not a substitute for advice on a specific case. References to legislation and case law are to the Italian texts unless stated otherwise.

Working on a case with an Italian connection?

Tell us about the case

Every enquiry is read personally. We reply with a first view on what can be done in Italy, which time limits apply and what your client should not sign. See how we work with foreign law firms.

More guides

Chat with us on WhatsApp