A judgment, a court settlement or an agreement with an Italian insurer is worth what it can be enforced for. In most cross-border personal injury cases the debtor is an insurer with assets in Italy, and enforcement is rarely the problem. But when the claim is litigated abroad against an Italian insurer, or the debtor is an individual or a company without insurance, the circulation of decisions between Italy and other countries becomes central. This guide sets out the rules within the European Union and the position of claimants outside it.
Within the European Union: Brussels I bis
Under Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012, a judgment given in a Member State is recognised in the other Member States without any special procedure (Article 36), and a judgment enforceable in the Member State of origin is enforceable in the others without any declaration of enforceability (Article 39). The party seeking enforcement produces a copy of the judgment and the certificate issued by the court of origin under Article 53 (Article 42). Recognition and enforcement can be refused only on the limited grounds of Article 45, such as manifest contrariety to public policy or failure to serve the defendant in time, on application of the person against whom enforcement is sought.
The same applies to court settlements (Article 59) and authentic instruments (Article 58). The Regulation applies to proceedings instituted on or after 10 January 2015 (Article 66).
Italian decisions abroad
An Italian first-instance civil judgment is provisionally enforceable by law (Article 282 of the Code of Civil Procedure). It can therefore be certified and enforced in another Member State even while an appeal is pending, subject to the power of the court addressed, where refusal of enforcement is sought, to stay the proceedings if an ordinary appeal has been lodged in Italy (Article 51 of Brussels I bis) or to limit or suspend enforcement in the cases of Article 44. A provisional award made by a criminal court in favour of a civil party is likewise immediately enforceable (Article 540 of the Code of Criminal Procedure).
Agreements reached through assisted negotiation are enforceable titles in Italy (Article 5 of Decree-Law No 132/2014). Their circulation abroad is less straightforward than that of a judgment or a court settlement, because they are neither: where enforcement abroad may be needed, a court settlement or a judgment on consent offers greater certainty.
Uncontested claims and small claims
For uncontested monetary claims, the European Enforcement Order under Regulation (EC) No 805/2004 and the European order for payment under Regulation (EC) No 1896/2006 remain available, although in practice they are rarely used in personal injury cases, where the amount is almost always disputed.
Outside the European Union
For Switzerland, Norway and Iceland the 2007 Lugano Convention provides a similar regime, with a declaration of enforceability. For the United Kingdom, the Brussels regime ceased to apply at the end of the transition period. The 2019 Hague Judgments Convention, in force for the European Union (except Denmark) since 1 September 2023 and for the United Kingdom since 1 July 2025, now provides a framework for recognition and enforcement between them, but only for judgments given in proceedings started after the Convention had effect between the two States. For earlier proceedings, and for other third countries, recognition of foreign judgments in Italy is governed by Articles 64 and following of Law No 218/1995, and recognition of Italian judgments abroad by the law of the country concerned.
Practical consequences
When choosing the forum, the question is not only where the claim is easier to bring, but where the result will be easiest to collect. Against an Italian insurer, an Italian judgment is enforced directly in Italy; a foreign judgment must circulate. Against an uninsured individual with assets in several countries, the choice may be different. For non-EU clients, the date on which proceedings are started can determine whether the Hague Convention applies.
Questions we are often asked
We obtained a judgment in Malta against an Italian insurer. Can it be enforced in Italy?
Yes, under Brussels I bis without any declaration of enforceability, with the certificate under Article 53. In practice, insurers usually pay once the judgment is final.
Can an Italian judgment under appeal be enforced abroad?
It is provisionally enforceable in Italy and can be certified for enforcement in other Member States, although, if the debtor applies for refusal of enforcement, the court addressed may stay the proceedings while the appeal is pending (Article 51).
Our client lives in England. Will an Italian judgment be recognised there?
For proceedings started after 1 July 2025, the 2019 Hague Judgments Convention applies between the EU and the UK. For earlier proceedings, the English common law rules on foreign judgments apply.
Sources
- Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012, Articles 36–45, 53, 58, 59, 66: EUR-Lex
- Hague Convention of 2 July 2019 on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Judgments: HCCH
- Lugano Convention 2007: EUR-Lex
- Code of Civil Procedure, Article 282; Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 540: Normattiva
- Decree-Law No 132/2014, Article 5: Normattiva
- Law No 218 of 31 May 1995 on private international law, Articles 64 ff.: Normattiva
If a decision needs to circulate between Italy and another country, tell us about the case: we reply personally.