When Rome II does not point to Italian law: common habitual residence and the escape clause

Article 4(2) and 4(3) of Rome II in road and holiday accidents, with the interaction with the 1971 Hague Convention in the courts of Convention States.
Reading time: about 5 minutes

The starting point under the Rome II Regulation is simple: the law of the country where the damage occurs. For an accident in Italy, that is Italian law. But the Regulation contains two exceptions that matter in exactly the kind of cases foreign firms see: holiday accidents between people from the same country, and accidents whose connection with Italy is only incidental. This guide explains when Italian law gives way, and how the 1971 Hague Convention can change the picture in some courts.

The general rule and its meaning

Article 4(1) of Regulation (EC) No 864/2007 points to the law of the country in which the damage occurs, irrespective of the country in which the event giving rise to it occurred and of the countries in which indirect consequences arise. For personal injury, the damage occurs where the injury is sustained. In Lazar (C-350/14, judgment of 10 December 2015), the Court of Justice held that the losses suffered by close relatives of a person who died in a road accident are indirect consequences: the relevant place remains the place of the accident, even if the relatives live, and suffer their loss, elsewhere.

Common habitual residence: Article 4(2)

Where the person claimed to be liable and the person sustaining damage both have their habitual residence in the same country when the damage occurs, the law of that country applies. A typical case is a collision in Italy between two cars driven by residents of the same country, or an injury to a passenger travelling in a car driven by a friend from home. The claim will then be governed by the law of their common residence, even though the accident occurred in Italy and the insurer of the vehicle may be the same as in a domestic case.

The rule is applied person by person. In a collision involving several vehicles, the relationship between two parties who share a residence may be governed by their home law, while the claims against a local driver remain governed by Italian law.

The escape clause: Article 4(3)

Where it is clear from all the circumstances that the tort is manifestly more closely connected with another country, that country’s law applies. A manifestly closer connection might be based on a pre-existing relationship between the parties, such as a contract closely connected with the tort. The clause is meant to be exceptional, and courts apply it restrictively.

What remains Italian even when Italian law does not apply

Article 17 requires the court, in assessing the conduct of the person liable, to take into account, as a matter of fact and where appropriate, the rules of safety and conduct in force at the place and time of the event. Italian traffic rules therefore remain relevant to liability whatever the applicable law. Article 16 preserves the overriding mandatory provisions of the forum.

Direct action against the insurer

Article 18 allows a direct action against the liability insurer if it is provided for by either the law applicable to the non-contractual obligation or the law applicable to the insurance contract. An Italian policy will normally be governed by Italian law, which grants the direct action, so the direct action is available even where Article 4(2) points to another law.

The 1971 Hague Convention

Under Article 28 of Rome II, the Regulation does not prejudice international conventions to which Member States were parties when it was adopted. Several Member States, including France, Spain, Belgium, the Netherlands, Austria, Poland and others, apply the Hague Convention of 4 May 1971 on the Law Applicable to Traffic Accidents. Its connecting factors differ from Rome II: in some circumstances it points to the law of the State where the vehicle is registered rather than the place of the accident. Italy and Malta are not parties. The Convention matters when a claimant domiciled in a Convention State sues at home, because the court there will apply the Convention instead of Rome II, and the applicable law may change with the forum.

Consequences for strategy

The applicable law determines heads of damage, valuation and limitation. When Article 4(2) points to the law of a country with higher awards for non-pecuniary loss than Italy, or vice versa, the choice can make a large difference. A careful analysis of habitual residence for each party, of the forum and of any Convention in force there should come before any valuation.

Questions we are often asked

Two German tourists collide in Italy. Which law applies?

As between them, German law under Article 4(2), if both are habitually resident in Germany. Italian traffic rules remain relevant to the assessment of conduct under Article 17.

Our client was a passenger in a car driven by a friend from home, hit by an Italian driver.

The claim against the Italian driver and insurer is governed by Italian law; any claim against the friend may be governed by the law of their common residence.

Does it matter where the relatives live?

Not for the applicable law: following Lazar, the relevant place is that of the accident.

Sources

  • Regulation (EC) No 864/2007 (Rome II), Articles 4, 16, 17, 18, 28: EUR-Lex
  • Court of Justice, C-350/14 Lazar: EUR-Lex
  • Hague Convention of 4 May 1971 on the Law Applicable to Traffic Accidents, status table: HCCH

If the applicable law is in doubt in a claim with an Italian connection, we can help analyse it. tell us about the case: we reply personally.

Written by
Picture of Avv. Roberta Scarpellini
Avv. Roberta Scarpellini

Member of the Milan Bar, leading Studio Legale Scarpellini. The firm handles only cases of serious personal injury and death, from road traffic collisions and medical liability, and works with law firms abroad on claims with an Italian connection. President of NEVRA ETS.

Avv. Roberta Scarpellini · Milan Bar · studioscarpellini.com

A note. This guide provides general information on Italian law, up to date at the date shown, and is not a substitute for advice on a specific case. References to legislation and case law are to the Italian texts unless stated otherwise.

Working on a case with an Italian connection?

Tell us about the case

Every enquiry is read personally. We reply with a first view on what can be done in Italy, which time limits apply and what your client should not sign. See how we work with foreign law firms.

More guides

Chat with us on WhatsApp