Negotiating with Italian insurers: offers, releases and when to litigate

How Italian insurers handle serious claims, how to read a reasoned offer, what a release really closes, payments on account and the point at which litigation becomes the better route.
Reading time: about 5 minutes

Most serious injury claims in Italy are resolved with the insurer, not in court. That makes the negotiation the decisive phase of the case, and the phase in which a foreign claimant is most exposed: the insurer controls the first reconstruction of the facts, the first medical examination and the first figure, and the statutory procedure moves on fixed deadlines. This guide explains how Italian insurers handle serious claims, how to read an offer, what a release means and when litigation becomes the better route.

The statutory claims procedure

For road traffic claims, Article 148 of the Private Insurance Code sets out the procedure. Once it receives a complete claim, the insurer has 90 days in personal injury cases to make a reasoned offer, stating the amount for each head of damage, or to give specific reasons for not making one. The injured person cannot refuse the medical examinations strictly needed to assess the damage. The insurance supervisor, IVASS, oversees compliance with these rules and can sanction insurers that breach them.

Where the insurer has grounds to suspect fraud, the deadlines can be suspended. In serious cases with clear facts this rarely applies, but it explains some delays.

The insurer’s first assessment

The offer rests on the insurer’s reconstruction of liability and on the report of its own forensic doctor. Both are starting points for negotiation, not findings. Typical weaknesses of a first offer include a percentage of permanent impairment assessed before the injuries have stabilised, an incomplete picture of temporary impairment, moral suffering valued at the minimum, no personalisation, pecuniary losses limited to documented past expenses, and a contribution of fault attributed to the victim without proof of its causal effect.

The response should be built on an independent medico-legal assessment and a full valuation of every head of damage, presented in the categories Italian law uses and with the evidence an Italian court would require.

Accepting, rejecting, receiving payment on account

The injured party can accept or reject the offer. Under Article 148, if the offer is not accepted, the insurer must nevertheless pay the amount offered, which is then set against the final settlement. This allows the client to receive funds without closing the claim. Article 147 of the Private Insurance Code also allows a victim in a state of need to ask the court for an interim payment during the proceedings.

The release and the settlement agreement

A final payment is made against a release, the quietanza, usually with a declaration that the claim is fully and finally settled. A settlement agreement (transazione) under Articles 1965 and following of the Civil Code is binding and cannot be annulled for an error of law on the questions that were the subject of the dispute (Article 1969). Once signed, reopening a claim because the damage turns out to be worse is very difficult.

When the victim is a minor or a person without full legal capacity, a settlement requires the authorisation of the guardianship judge (Articles 320 and 374 of the Civil Code). Insurers will not pay without it, and the procedure should be factored into the timing.

What can be included in a settlement

A complete settlement covers non-pecuniary damage, past and future pecuniary losses, interest and revaluation, and the costs of the pre-action phase. Italian courts generally treat reasonable legal and medico-legal costs incurred before litigation as recoverable items of damage. Where social security institutions or employers have paid benefits with a right of recovery, their position must be addressed so that the settlement is not later challenged.

When to litigate

Litigation becomes the better route when the gap between the offer and a realistic valuation is wide and rests on issues a court expert would resolve in the claimant’s favour; when liability is disputed and the evidence is strong; or when the insurer does not respect the statutory deadlines. The decision should weigh the length and cost of Italian proceedings against the likely improvement. A well-prepared pre-action expert assessment, or the use of the criminal proceedings, can shift the negotiation without a full trial.

Out-of-court negotiation as a discipline

Negotiation with Italian insurers rewards preparation more than pressure. A claim presented with a complete medico-legal file, a valuation under the applicable tables, documented pecuniary losses and a credible litigation plan is treated differently from a request for a figure. The goal is the fullest compensation the evidence supports, reached within a timeframe that serves the client.

Questions we are often asked

The insurer has offered a sum and asked our client to sign quickly. What should we do?

Do not sign a release before the injuries have stabilised and the offer has been checked against an independent assessment. If the client needs funds, the offered amount can be received on account without closing the claim.

Can we negotiate with the insurer’s representative in our own country?

Yes, for victims resident in another Member State injured by an insured vehicle: Directive 2009/103/EC requires each motor insurer to have a claims representative there, who must give a reasoned response within three months. The valuation, however, remains an Italian one.

Are interest and revaluation negotiable?

They are part of the damage. Damages in tort are calculated at current values, with compensatory interest for the delay, and should be included in any settlement figure.

Sources

  • Private Insurance Code, Legislative Decree No 209/2005, Articles 145, 147, 148: Normattiva
  • Civil Code, Articles 320, 374, 1965–1976: Normattiva
  • IVASS, the Italian insurance supervisory authority: ivass.it
  • Directive 2009/103/EC, Articles 21 and 22: EUR-Lex

If an Italian insurer has made an offer to your client, send us the details. We reply personally, with a first view on whether it reflects the value of the claim.

Written by
Picture of Avv. Roberta Scarpellini
Avv. Roberta Scarpellini

Member of the Milan Bar, leading Studio Legale Scarpellini. The firm handles only cases of serious personal injury and death, from road traffic collisions and medical liability, and works with law firms abroad on claims with an Italian connection. President of NEVRA ETS.

Avv. Roberta Scarpellini · Milan Bar · studioscarpellini.com

A note. This guide provides general information on Italian law, up to date at the date shown, and is not a substitute for advice on a specific case. References to legislation and case law are to the Italian texts unless stated otherwise.

Working on a case with an Italian connection?

Tell us about the case

Every enquiry is read personally. We reply with a first view on what can be done in Italy, which time limits apply and what your client should not sign. See how we work with foreign law firms.

More guides

Chat with us on WhatsApp